mandag 30. januar 2012

Murphy om mafia-argumentet.

For dere som fortsatt trenger å overbevises om at det er absolutt ingenting stater kan gjøre mer effektivt enn frie, private individer/organisasjoner: hør BoB Murphy ta for seg mafia-argumentet når det kommer til private sikkerhetsfirmaer.

Les hele artikkelen hans her.

It is not enough to demonstrate that a state of private-property anarchy could degenerate into ceaseless war, where no single group is strong enough to subjugate all challengers, and hence no one can establish “order.” After all, communities living under a State degenerate into civil war all the time. We should remember that the frequently cited cases of Colombia and now Iraq are not demonstrations of anarchy-turned-into-chaos, but rather examples of government-turned-into-chaos.

For the warlord objection to work, the statist would need to argue that a given community would remain lawful under a government, but that the same community would break down into continuous warfare if all legal and military services were privatized.




For en komplett innføring i hvordan private sikkerhetsfirmaer kunne fungert, hør David Friedmans (ja, sønnen til Milton) foredrag her:

Ingen kommentarer:

Legg inn en kommentar